Great Britain’s Rutter won silver in a dramatic and controversial final of the women’s skeet shooting.
The 26-year-old finished in a tie of 55 shots out of 60 targets with Chile’s Francisca Crovetto Chadid.
They went to a shoot-off and were still tied after three rounds but, in a moment of contention, Rutter was called to have missed a shot which slow motion replays appeared to show she hit.
She contested the call but shooting’s version of a video assistant referee (VAR) or Hawkeye is not in use at the Olympics and the judges did not overturn the decision.
Crovetto Chadid, 34, struck with both her next shots to make history and clinch her country’s first ever shooting gold medal.
Former world champion Rutter takes a medal, though, just over three months after giving birth to her first child, Tommy, on 25 April and was surprised by her husband at the end, who had brought their son to the final.